Chapter 3: Rebuilding a Community

In the days following the fire, people traveled by wagon from neighboring communities to see the ruins of Utica.

The people of Utica, however, were already looking ahead.

James Holt converted his barn into temporary living quarters.

Benjamin Ellsworth immediately began building temporary sheds and stables, declaring that he intended to have a new barn as soon as possible.

Neighboring farmers cared for the twelve or thirteen families left homeless by the fire, providing shelter and assistance while the village began rebuilding.

Unfortunately, hardship continued. Tom Hammer's property was broken into by tramps who stole tobacco, cigars, and canned fruit.

With much of the village destroyed, land was inexpensive, and many believed it was the perfect opportunity to rebuild.

Only one store, the railroad depot, and the warehouse remained standing after the fire.

Insurance agents quickly arrived in Utica, writing new policies for those determined to start over.

By April 1886, signs of recovery were everywhere.

James Holt was constructing a new shop.

Simon Nick was building a skating rink.

George Evans had completed the walls of his new store.

Beers was grading ground for a new hotel.

The Ellsworth horse racing track was once again being rented for the season, and Benjamin Ellsworth planned to race a pair of his famous Gold Dust colts.

Around this same time, J. Moorhead, a livery operator from St. Paul, visited Utica to inspect Benjamin Ellsworth's horses. He purchased three animals, including Ellsworth's prized Gold Dust team.

It has long been believed that the proceeds from the sale of these horses helped finance the construction of Benjamin Ellsworth's new farm buildings, including the barn that still stands today.